Christmas hovers at the end of the week. While this year my husband and I are rather impressed with ourselves for having gifts bought for all of our extended family members and shipped enough in advance that we didn’t have to worry about shipping the boxes priority – in the same week we got ourselves packed to move across the country no less - we haven’t bought a thing for our two-year old son. We’ve barely bought anything for each other.
Every year at Christmas, we have the same conversation regarding gift giving with slight variations depending on our circumstances. Mainly, that we don’t want to give gifts merely because we think we have to, or it’s expected of us, or because the calendar says it’s what we do on this day. We revisit the rules we have for each other when it comes to gift giving occasions: we don’t buy crap or just anything for each other so there’s something to open under the tree, and, if we don’t like what we have given each other, we have to say so, not lie and shove the item into the back of the closet until the next move when we can quietly slide the item into the donation pile.
We have reasons for these rules. One is we have both been the victims of bad gifts, not so much from each other (because we honor the second rule of telling the truth) but from well meaning friends or family members, who do not have our rules, but other rules. Mainly, no matter how bad the gift is you lie and say thank you, and that you absolutely love it. If you tell the truth – so we have learned – the giver accuses you of being ungrateful and rude. Usually a big display of pouting, offence taken and hurt feelings follows after telling the giver in the nicest way possible that their gift, while well meant, was just not your taste or style.
We have a couple of instances that fall into our family Hall of Fame for bad gifts from people who prefer you to lie as you express your gratitude. One year for Christmas, we had friends give us an item for our home, the kind of thing they would expect to see prominently displayed when they came over for a visit. They loved their gift to us, they gazed at it, delighted in it, were awed by it. At one point, after we had done our duty and put it on display, the wife said, “Oh, we so love the traditional styles.”
“Oh, interesting.” I said. “We’re more mid-century modern people.”
“The back of it is really nice.” My husband said, “Mind if I turn it around?”
After the couple left, we talked about what we should do. The gift was one of those items that the couple said over and over we would be able to enjoy for years, it could become a fixture in our home, something our children would remember being present in their childhoods. We considered our fate of displaying somebody else’s tastes in our home. My husband and I then did what anyone else would do in our position; we put all of our things into storage, and left the country. Our hope of course is that when we have a home again and our friends visit, they will have forgotten what they gave us or that we can easily claim it got lost or broken in the move.
We have a few other of instances in our Hall of Fame that generally go along the same lines. Every time after we say our obligatory thank you and we hang up the phone, I turn to my husband and say, “Don’t you ever – and I mean EVER – lie to me the way we just lied to them.”
Sometimes my husband defends the lying and the fake gratitude. “We have to say thank you and say we like it. It’s a gift. They don’t have to give us anything.”
Honestly, I’d rather receive nothing.
There’s disappointment in a bad gift, not just the let down of not receiving something you like, or that someone took time and effort to shop or even make your gift, only to have you not like it, but also the disappointing realization that the person who gave you the gift doesn’t really know you, and because they get offended when you try to convey your preferences, they aren’t really interested in getting to know you. Rather, they prefer their version of you, the person they think you are and the image of you they see in their minds when they think of you. They don’t like it when you try to swap the person they think you are for the real one.
Alas, my husband and I now bear the task of raising our son in the sticky dance of gift giving and thank-you-saying and even I-know-I said-it’s-wrong-and disrespectful-to-lie-but-this-distant-relative/friend-honestly-prefers-it or this person is okay with you telling the truth and here are a couple of ways to say that you appreciate their effort, but it wasn’t in your style.
I actually really love giving good gifts, and while the art of receiving bad gifts is kind of one I routinely fail at, I do love spending the time and energy to give a good gift.
This art is one I look forward to raising my son in, because like so many things in parenting, it comes down to compassion and the ability to put one’s self into some one else’s shoes. Giving a good gift means you don’t buy things you like for yourself, but with the other person in mind. I can easily say to my son, “Yes, we now live in Brooklyn and we love it, but that doesn’t mean we should buy Grand Dad that Yankees baseball cap. Grand Dad actually hates the Yankees and is obsessed with the Boston Red Sox. No, we shouldn’t buy that cap for Auntie. While she has lived in Brooklyn for eight years, she rarely watches baseball and has never in her life worn a baseball cap or any article of clothing with a logo.”
Still, Christmas is just a few days away. While my son has boxes of gifts from grandparents, aunts and uncles, my husband and I have decided to wait on his big gift. Last night, we went to the Brooklyn Holiday Flea Market and bought stocking stuffers for all of us, and engaged in the yearly habit of shopping with the person you’re buying for - waiting until the other had turned their back, realizing we didn’t actually have cash on hand, having to borrow the spouse’s wallet to buy the spouse’s gift and laughing about it all the while. Afterward, with Auntie, we planned our Christmas all day menu, so we can squeeze in all our favorite traditional foods and favorite activities (mainly the Christmas afternoon nap). With less gifts – but good gifts – bought, we’ll have plenty of time and space to enjoy the time with each other.